Maritime Safety Devices Fail Under Real-World Conditions, Study Reveals

In a recent study published in the *MATEC Web of Conferences*, which translates to the *Materials Science and Engineering Conference Proceedings*, researchers from the National Institute for Research and Development in Mine Safety and Protection to Explosion – INSEMEX Petroşani, led by Jitea Ilie-Ciprian, put maritime pyrotechnic articles through their paces. The goal? To see how well these critical safety devices hold up under the kind of rough-and-tumble conditions they might face out on the open water.

The team tested 216 samples of hand flares and buoyant smoke signals, subjecting them to extreme temperatures, water immersion, and exposure to heptane vapors—conditions designed to mimic real-life maritime emergencies. Most of the devices performed as expected, but not all. Some failed to ignite after being submerged, while others sparked unexpectedly when exposed to flammable vapors. There were also issues with structural degradation, delayed ignition, and shorter-than-expected signal duration.

So, what does this mean for the maritime industry? Well, it suggests that current testing and certification standards might not be as rigorous as they need to be. “The findings support the need for updated testing protocols, regular re-certification, and independent laboratory validation,” Ilie-Ciprian said. In other words, the way these devices are tested today might not be giving us the full picture of how they’ll perform in a real crisis.

For maritime professionals, this research highlights the importance of reliability in distress signaling. If a flare or smoke signal fails when you need it most, the consequences could be dire. The study’s recommendations—like more realistic testing conditions and independent validation—could lead to safer, more dependable products. And for manufacturers, there’s an opportunity to step up and meet these higher standards, potentially gaining a competitive edge in the market.

The study, published in *MATEC Web of Conferences*, serves as a wake-up call for the industry. By pushing for better testing and certification, we can ensure that when mariners reach for a flare or smoke signal, they can trust it will work when it matters most.

Scroll to Top